Taipei, Thursday, November 26, 2015 08:45 (GMT+8)
partly cloudy
Commentary: Apple being dragged into US-China trade war
Heng-An Su, Taipei; Joseph Tsai, DIGITIMES [Friday 21 October 2011]

Since January 2011, three events have occurred in China which have led some upstream component suppliers to believe there is a conspiracy by the China government to try to suppress Apple's supply chain. The moves are said to be counter attacks which are part of China's trade war with the US.

In January, five non-governmental organizations (NGOs) in China published reports accusing Apple's supply chain partners in China of creating massive pollution in the country. This was followed up at the end of August, when the NGOs published a pollution map of China, mapping the upstream supply firms and linking them to claims of huge environmental pollution issues in the surrounding regions. The writers of the reports cited Apple's own 2011 supply partner responsibility report to highlight the firm control Apple maintains over its supply chain, in ordered to emphasize that Apple must take ultimate responsibility for any excess pollution caused by its upstream partners.

On October 15, China Central Television (CCTV), a government-backed media outlet, broadcast a documentary titled "Another Side of Apple" (title translated from Chinese), which citied environmental organizations linking 27 of Apple's upstream suppliers including Foxconn Electronics (Hon Hai Precision Industry), Compeq and Unimicron with environmental pollution.

After the TV program was broadcast, other media outlets in China jumped on the topic leading to widespread coverage of the issues and allegations.

It is believed the controversy following the documentary's broadcast directly triggered the third event to hit Apple's supply chain, as on October 17, just days after the original air-date, Apple's upstream chassis supplier Catcher Technology was ordered by the Suzhou local government to halt production at its facilities in the district due to complaints by local residents that the plants were releasing noxious gasses into the surrounding area. The incident has generated massive speculation across the IT market in China, with some news organizations even speculating that other upstream suppliers, including Foxconn, TPK and Wintek, may also be forced to suspend operations in other parts of China.

The incident involving Catcher (which has been dubbed "The Poison Apple") has significantly affected the stock prices of Apple's other upstream suppliers including Largan Precision, Genius Electronic Optical and TPK, to the extent that Taiwan's Minister of Economic Affairs, Shih Yen-Shiang, has needed to publicly downplay Catcher's troubles as an isolated incident.

Speculation in the industry has linked the Catcher incident with the recent trade war between the US and China, rousing suspicions that the orders to disrupt Catcher's business came from the central government and were motived out of retaliation against the US government. Taiwan's ODMs are pawns caught in the cross-fire between the two economic giants.

It is alleged that the China government has also had a hand in the disruption US-based Wal-Mart has been facing to its operations in China.

Realtime news
  • TEEMA urges Taiwan government to take action on China hostile headhunting

    Before Going to Press | 10h 52min ago

  • ASE to expand workforce at Chungli facility

    Before Going to Press | 10h 53min ago

  • All-in-one PC shipments to drop over 10% in 2015

    Before Going to Press | 10h 59min ago

  • Acer launches Predator series products in Taiwan, eying opportunity from IT Month show

    Before Going to Press | 11h ago

  • Taiwan PCB production value increases over 7% sequentially in 3Q15

    Before Going to Press | 11h 7min ago

  • D-Link sees strong smart home product sales in Europe

    Before Going to Press | 11h 11min ago

  • Korea government to invest US$110 million into wearables development, says report

    Before Going to Press | 11h 19min ago

  • Global LCD TV shipments to grow 2% in 2016

    Before Going to Press | 11h 24min ago

  • Himax obtains design-wins for smartphone-use force touch solutions

    Before Going to Press | 11h 27min ago

  • ZTE receives government funds to accelerate development of in-house mobile processors

    Before Going to Press | 11h 31min ago

  • TSMC may raise dividend for 2016

    Before Going to Press | 11h 32min ago

  • Sales of 40-inch TVs in Japan strong in October

    Before Going to Press | 11h 34min ago

  • Taiwan notebook makers seeking lower chip quotes for 2016

    Before Going to Press | 11h 35min ago

  • TWM withdraws from bidding for 2,500-2,600MHz bands

    Before Going to Press | 11h 38min ago

  • Digitimes Research: Japan telecom operators offering household robots to boost revenues

    Before Going to Press | 11h 48min ago

View more
Display panels for wearable devices
Taiwan server shipment forecast and industry analysis, 2015
2015 global notebook demand forecast
  • Wireless broadband developments in Southeast Asia markets

    As of 2013, the 10 ASEAN nations had a total of over 700 million mobile subscriptions, with the CAGR from 2003-2013 reaching 24%. This Digitimes Research Special Report analyzes the various mobile broadband markets in ASEAN and looks at the respective trends in 4G LTE development for those markets.

  • 2015 global tablet demand forecast

    This Digitimes Research Special Report provides a 2015 forecast for the global tablet market and analyzes the strategies of key market players such as Google, Apple, Intel, and Microsoft.

  • 2015 China smartphone panel trend forecast

    This Digitimes Research Special Report analyzes the strategies of key China-based major panel makers BOE, Tianma and IVO for attacking the different market segments through technology and pricing, and their relationship to local vendors Huawei, Lenovo, ZTE, Xiaomi and Coolpad.